The Monaco Supreme Court has opened the door to potentially overturning a final judgment requiring the State to pay the Caroli group €209 million in compensation, in an unprecedented decision that could have major consequences for one of the Principality’s most costly legal disputes.

In a ruling delivered on Wednesday, November 18, the Tribunal Suprême accepted that a decision which has already become final may, in exceptional circumstances, be reconsidered if it is subsequently established that fraud or an exceptionally serious irregularity affected the proceedings, Monaco-Matin reports.

The case centres on the abandoned development of the Esplanade des Pêcheurs, for which the government was ordered to compensate property developer Caroli Immo after withdrawing from an agreement to build on the site.

The original project, awarded to the developer in 2014, involved the construction of residential properties and a museum intended to house the archaeological collections of Franck Goddio. The government later abandoned the scheme, arguing that it would compromise infrastructure needed for the Monaco Grand Prix.

The withdrawal led to a series of legal proceedings, culminating in a major ruling against the State. In 2020, the Tribunal Suprême, then presided over by Didier Linotte, confirmed compensation of €137 million. With accumulated interest, the amount has since risen to approximately €209 million.

The government subsequently sought to have the earlier judgments withdrawn, arguing that the proceedings may have been affected by alleged partiality on the part of Linotte. The former president was charged in June 2025 as part of a judicial investigation into suspected corruption and influence peddling connected to the Esplanade des Pêcheurs affair.

The State argued that its constitutional right to a fair trial had been compromised, alleging that Linotte had maintained close links with lawyers acting for Caroli, including individuals described as unofficial representatives.

Caroli’s legal team, meanwhile, relied on the principle of res judicata, which protects the finality of court judgments. Lawyers representing Linotte also argued that allegations and suspicions should not be treated as proof of wrongdoing. The former judge sought €500,000 in damages, claiming that his reputation had been harmed. The court rejected his claim, as well as an application to intervene from property companies linked to businessman Patrice Pastor.

The latest ruling does not, however, cancel the compensation award or establish that the original proceedings were fraudulent.

Instead, the Supreme Court has accepted the government’s application to seek a reversal of its earlier decisions, while making any eventual reconsideration dependent on the outcome of the criminal proceedings against Linotte. The court has indicated that a definitive criminal conviction would be required before it could proceed with that step.

Consequently, it has suspended its consideration of the case until the criminal investigation and any subsequent appeals or further legal challenges have been concluded.

This means the State’s liability to Caroli remains in place for now, and interest continues to accumulate while the legal process remains unresolved. A final decision on whether the compensation judgment can be overturned could therefore be several years away.

The ruling nevertheless establishes a significant legal precedent in Monaco by recognising that even a final Supreme Court judgment may be challenged in exceptional circumstances involving proven fraud or serious procedural irregularities.

For the government, it offers a possible route to contesting a financial liability that has grown substantially since the original award. For Caroli, the compensation remains legally enforceable unless and until the court decides otherwise.

The long-running Esplanade des Pêcheurs dispute is therefore far from over, with the eventual outcome now closely tied to the separate criminal proceedings.